Dear Dr. Neder:

This seems silly to me, but I am always in favor of a second opinion.

My boyfriend of 1 ? years and I are considering moving in together. Well, I suggested it and now it is on the table. You hit the nail on the head with your articles (http://www.beingaman.com/articleviewer.asp?ID=341, http://www.beingaman.com/articleviewer.asp?ID=235, http://www.beingaman.com/articleviewer.asp?ID=216 and http://www.beingaman.com/articleviewer.asp?ID=270), I do want our relationship to progress (bad reason to move in together after reading these articles) but I also want to know if we are wasting our time. A year and a half seems like a long time.

We alternate between homes, mine on the weekdays and his on the weekends. We do not sleep well together! Rare is a morning when we both wake up feeling refreshed. My thinking is well lets just figure it out NOW, we are either going to make it or we should move on.

Furthermore, he is a difficult fellow. He is military born and bred and his emotions consist entirely of logic. He looks at our relationship in a completely logical fashion to the point where he weighs the pros and cons and must have decided the pros outweigh the cons.

What I am driving at is insecurity. I want to move in to get to that level of understanding and comprehension of what the other person is about. Our issue is that I am an emotional female and he is an overly logical male.

I am sorry if it seems like I am writing an advice columnist, but it seems like you have a handle on when to, and when not to make these relationship changes.

Hello!

A second opinion seems silly to you??? Actually, I *am* an advice columnist, so it doesn't seem odd to me at all. Here's what's going on:

You two really are opposites. That can be a very good thing - or a very bad thing depending on how you handle it. If he's logic and you're emotion, that's going to make for some very challenging times indeed! It's far better to have a balance between them as you both not only need to get your own needs met, but you also need to be able to understand (and sometimes adopt) the other's point of view. Being on such opposite sides of the fence may create great tension between you. I first suggest that you both work on this as a goal in your relationship; to gain a better handle on the other's methods to understanding and dealing with both joys and problems within the relationship.

With regards to moving in together, let's consider a few points:

First of all, you mentioned that "...a year and a half seems like a long time..." My question is: for what? Do you think that you need to move in together or be married simply because of the passage of time? That's very short-sighted in my humble. Living together, dating, marriage, etc., are not "relationships". They are FORMATS of relationships! Do you understand the difference? It's a critical distinction. The format has nothing whatsoever to do with the quality other than the more "tight" the format the greater the conflicts in a less-than-perfect relationship; and let's face it - there is no perfect relationship! I would strongly urge you to forget the timeframes and focus on the quality instead. Make decisions for your relationship based on what you want to grow or change - not because a certain amount of time has passed.

You mentioned that you and he don't wake up refreshed from sleeping together. Can you learn to, or are you going to start sleeping in different beds? This is another critical question to answer as if you wind up in different beds, or even different rooms you're going to quickly question your reasoning for being together in the first place. Do you (or he) really need just a roommate? Just because 1.5 years have past, do you really think that if you don't move in together you're not "going anywhere" with the relationship? Again, that's short-sighted.

Things like moving in together and even getting married isn't going to solve your insecurity problems. This is internal - not external. It's just as easy for one person to cheat when living together or being married as it is when you're just dating. That's not going to solve your insecurity issues; and in fact, it may even make it worse. When tensions arise in the relationship are you going to assume that he's out with other women? I can assure you that they will arise as that's part of being under the same roof. Insecurities need to be handled before you consider such a drastic change in your relationship format.

All in all, the reasons for moving in together should stem from having a terrific, solid relationship in the first place and both parties wanting to grow all those good things. It should never be done (nor should marriage) in order to solve other problems. It exists for its own benefit and for its own reasons.

Best regards...

Have a love, dating, relationship, sex or man/woman question? I answer all email. You can write to me at dwneder@beingaman.com for answers. For more information about my books, "Being a Man in a Woman's World" (volumes I & II), and other products visit: www.beingaman.com. Check out the discussion group at: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/beingaman.

Copyright (c) 2005, Dr. Dennis W. Neder
All rights reserved.

More articles

Too Shy To Try
Breaking Up
The Art Of Selling
The Test
Meeting That Special Someone
First Date Checklist
The First Contact in an Email Relationship
The Sexless, Passionless Lifestyle
The Big "O"
Communication and "Sexual Conversion" Part 1
Communication and "Sexual Conversion" Part 2
The Perils of Internet Dating
Are Women Sluts?
The Secret To Getting Men to Commit
The 'Independent Woman' – a Recipe for Disaster
I Can’t Get Him To Leave!
Dating While Still Being In a Relationship
Am I Sabotaging My Relationship?
Dating Interracially
Does My Girlfriend Love Me?
The Mathematics of Moving In Together
Sex Only Relationships
The Harsh Reality
The Farmer's Milk
Friendships and False Hopes
I Love Getting Gifts!
Would Setting Him Up Be Wrong?
Men Won’t Approach Me!
The Better Part of Discretion
How Do I Tell Him To Tell Me?
Marriage Isn’t a Relationship, It’s a Format
In a Sea of Messages, This One’s Mixed
What We Have Here Is a Failure to Communicate!
How Do I Know?
Physically Close, Emotionally Distant
You Have To Learn The Game!
Knowledge IS Power - When You Have It!
My Flaky Girl Problem
How to Handle the Silent Treatment
Strong Women, Submissive Women
Is She Just a Habit?
How Big a Gift is Appropriate?
Break-Up Fake-Out, or Move Out Without the Lout?
Why It's So Hard To Not Be A "Nice Guy"
Do YOU Have Different Rules For Women?
Why Can't I Meet Someone That's Available?
Building Experience From Inexperience
Do Men Respect Women?
How Do I Make It Through?
I Feel Like I've Been Waiting Forever!
The Three Keys to the Cold Approach
The Magic of the Approach
Interviewing For the Love of Your Life
Grow Yourself, Grow Your Relationship
A Sensitive Sensitivity Problem
Messing Up The Perfect Thing
It's the Choices You Make Now
Should I Call to Confirm a Date?
Handling Call-Backs, Messages and Setting Dates
Moving On and Knowing That You’ve Moved On
I Don’t Want to Look Like an Idiot!
Find What Makes You Happy
Dating Rights Verse Dating Responsibilities
Getting Past Your Past
How Women Can Approach Men
Sexless Relationship, Missing Boyfriend
The Guy That Wants to Get Married
Learn to Kiss, Damn it!
Talk is Cheap – Learn to Do It Right!